UPCOMING AT AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE

Spring Seasonal Meal Planning

Friday, March 5, 2010

28-day real-food challenge article: a response

I am sure everyone read the CNN article about the 28-day Real-Food Challenge created by one of the best real-food bloggers out there: Jenny at Nourished Kitchen. I was excited to see this it, and though I had some issues with the article itself, what I really couldn't believe was the vast spread of negative comments. Now, opinions are fine, but that doesn't mean that people should just say anything that pops into their mind without thought. (Take note: the degrading comments about how the challenge was only feasible for the hopelessly out-of-touch high upper-class housewives.) I am so disgusted by the comments that instead of contributing to keeping the post high in search traffic by adding my input, I decided to state it here. Whine-filled comments:

  1. This real-food challenge is just too hard. Well, I'm sorry: what does the word 'challenge' mean to you? Did Jenny call it the Real-Food Fun Experiment? I didn't think so.
  2. Only well-to-do (read: rich) people can afford this. Try this: look up real-food blogs that focus on frugality. Find: well over half of the blogs are written with a focus on eating traditional food on a budget. Dried beans are cheaper than canned, fresh pasta cheaper than boxed, etc. Homemade is alomost always cheaper than 'convenience' and the savings mean we can 'splurge' on good meat and dairy products. Not that I consider avoiding huge medical bills a 'splurge.' 
  3. The phrase 'real-food' doesn't mean anything because all food is real. A sure sign of a losing argument: hair-splitting over word meanings. If you'd prefer us to use something like 'food, that is unprocessed towards loss of nutrients or addition of chemical preservatives/GMOs, and prepared according to traditional methods' we could- but would it fit on a twitter hashtag? 
  4. Normal people don't have time to (insert food preperation here). Really? You don't have time to grind grain? Well, read Jenny's blog- you don't have to- but I have two kids I watch full-time, go to school part-time, write for two blogs part-time and work part-time for my mom's real estate office. (Yes, I'm in RE too- for all you who insulted Jenny's apparent like of qualifications.) Yet, I have time to grind grain, and make yougurt, butter and pasta. Have you heard of a blender? How about a food processor? I can make homemade pasta in less active time than it takes to open a box of macaroni and throw it in boiling water.
This challenge was all about priorities. Do you care more about having time to watch TV and money to spend on Oreos? Then real food isn't for you. Bashing an intelligent, determined woman who wants the best for her family won't do anything except make you look foolish. (Kind of like the 'expert' quoted in the article who said you can find healthy food in a package- like lowfat milk and canned vegetables.) As Nina Planck was quoted, "Real food costs more, because it's worth more. You need to think about where and how you want to spend your money... I don't need another sweater, but I have to feed my kids every day."

I am happy to share this at Fight Back Fridays.

4 comments:

  1. motherhen68Mar 5, 2010 07:05 AM
    BRAVO! I am trying to limit my exposure to negativity during Lent, so I avoided the majority of the comments. IMO, you'll never win with mainstream people. They want what they want when they want it, no matter the price they'll pay down the road (in terms of health).

    Great post, I feel exactly the same way that you do. Kudos for Jenny. I know it couldn't have been easy to make herself a target to ugly people.
    ReplyDelete
  2. AngelaMar 5, 2010 08:45 AM
    I didn't read the comments because I have gotten used to the fact that the majority of folks want an easy fix. They don't want to actually understand the reasoning behind the NT diet.

    I agree wholeheartedly with your comments.

    What takes more time? Clipping coupons to get cheap SAD items such as processed cereals and junk foods or soaking oats for oatmeal? Making some homemade healthy treats?
    ReplyDelete
  3. Kitchen StewardshipMar 5, 2010 07:43 PM
    Shelley,
    Awesome assessment. My jaw was on the floor when I read those comments at the article! Crazy. Jenny got some good traffic who appreciate real food, though, too, so that was great exposure. Thanks for being real with us!
    :) Katie
    ReplyDelete
  4. mahmommyMar 7, 2010 04:37 AM
    Thanks all! Motherhen- I know, I too try to limit the negativity and read the article days before going back to read the comments- then I couldn't stop (like the train wreck you can't look away from.)
    Angela- absolutely! I used to be an avid coupon clipper(now it's harder to find coupons for real food)- it took more active time than making NT syle food.
    Katie- thanks. I know, some of the comments were awful, but hopefully they led some people to actually read Jenny's blog.
    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Real Food made real easy

Is traditional food stressful for you? Not sure how to make real foods with your schedule? Worried that real food means difficult, costly meals?



Meal planning by MAHM offers guidance-

how to: include real foods- soaking and fermenting

how to: plan ahead for these cooking methods



includes:

A full week of meal plans, 3 meals a day, and snacks!

Exclusive recipes and tips.



more information~

sample

subscriptions



Now offering- Nutritional Coaching at 25 % off

until April 15th!

~an individualized approach~